I think the liner is a better choice since it also protects the back and upper portion of the second row seats. The leather or vinyl in that area may bet torn with a paw. Just scotch guard it before putting it on.
We don't have anything in back for our Golden (cargo net is great tho to keep her from hopping over the seats -- she likes to ride shotgun, even if someone else already is!).
I'd guess the liner is better and here's why: It's softer with no edges. The tray is harder (tho still flexible) plastic which might not be as comfy, which of course is the primary criteria for any Golden's human.
Have had the tray from day one and just bought the liner today (guess I'll have to update my profile). I found that the tray works just fine for normal, everyday use, such as hauling grocery bags, and did a good job when the dog was travelling in his kennel (wire cage) which was tied down with bungees. However, I wanted the added side and seat protection for times when I'm hauling golf gear for 4 and things like the Christmas tree -- which we're getting tomorrow. I'm glad I have both, 'cause now I have the added versatility.
By the way, the design of the liner is top-notch. They thought of everything, including openings for the subwoofer (mesh) and the cargo compartment latch mechanism... great job!
Question: Those of you who have the liner -- did you get a carrying case with your purchase, or was this an additional cost? Thanks.
Though I don't have my MDX yet, I've been hauling dogs in SUV's for twenty years. Pierre has the right idea. The dog belongs in a kennel in the back for a whole bunch of reasons.
Much cleaner for not only the floor and sides, but also the windows.
The back of your MDX will eventually smell like a wet dog no matter much you wash the MDX (and dog).
Imbeded dog hair in carpet is extremely difficult to get out.
It is much safer for your dog in case of an accident or sudden breaks. (My mom tells the story of how one she had to lock the brakes on her Subaru and her German Short Hair tumbled all the way from the back, then between the front seats and up against the dash.
You can carry something else in back and not worry that it gets trampled or eaten.
My dog actually prefers the kennel. She jumps right in, her water dish is there, and usually she goes right to sleep.
Also Pierre for your info, WalMart (if they have them up in Canada) carries tree bags for about 3 bucks. They are basically big plastic bags that slip over the tree before it goes in the car. Not exactly environmentally friendly but will save the interior of your new MDX.
Yeah, we elected to go the kennel route right away for safety reasons more than anything else. Plus, the dog really likes it there.
We do have Wal-Marts. The tree lot guys also provide the bags for FREE when you buy the tree, so that was easy. However, I still like the liner for the overall protection it offers. I may just get a cheap duffel bag to store the liner when it's not in use if I can't get my hands on the "official" storage bag...
I just purchased an 05 model, it does not have the navigation screen. I was wondering if i purchased the navigation unit would it work in my model? It looks like the unit i have has the same plug, but an extra smaller plug as well.
I am planing to buy roof rack for my MDX 2018. I have base model.
Intend to buy is to save shipment cost of my IKEA king mattress.
What will you recommend. It would be my first accessory since I got MDX.
Hi. Im new to the forum and ive noticed that it is nearly impossible to find nice ground effects mods for my X. Instead of buying one for a similar truck and chopping it. I decided to fabricate my own and im thinking of making a bunch if people are interested in making their mdx look more sport...
We just bought a 2014 MDX and I'd like to purchase some accessories. Heavy duty floor mats, advance running boards and roof rails (OEM parts). Does anyone have a recommendation for where to buy them that has good prices?