They should for the interior flooring has not changed. The difference is the 2010+ have a softer but higher lip than the 2007. I prefer the older 2007 version since the soft lip is not staying flush with door sill inside fender.
Before posting the for sale, I checked the passenger side with the 2009 and they were the same. If you want I can check the other two pieces as well - I have the 2009 boxed now.
To add some clarification - these mats have had no more than 30,000 miles of use and mostly driver side (my 2009 Tech was lease returned for my 2012 Advance) and were never actually exposed to mud/salt etc; at worst just rain from dripping shoes
Your new all weather OEM mats will look just like those after a month especially if you are the NE and MW - I know I used to live there